Photo-Ionization Studies of Nebulae

Peter A.M. van Hoof

Thesis supervisors:

Stuart Pottasch
Thijs van der Hulst
Rens Waters
Thijs de Graauw

PhD awarded on 19 September 1997

Kapteyn Institute, Rijks Universiteit Groningen, The Netherlands



Abstract

The main goal of this thesis is to make a contribution to the understanding of post-AGB and PN evolution by trying to improve the methods for modeling spectroscopic data. A particular emphasis has been put on the modeling of infrared data from IRAS and ISO. One of the basic problems in nebular research is that no reliable and accurate methods are available to determine even the basic physical parameters of the nebulae. One can argue that photo-ionization modeling is the most promising approach to improve on this situation. Therefore we have constructed a new method to determine the physical parameters of PN using the photo-ionization code Cloudy written by Gary J. Ferland. This photo-ionization code was chosen because it is widely used and has been tested for many different physical conditions. To make the code more suitable for our purposes, including the modeling of ISO spectra, an extensive amount of new code was added. However, before this method can be applied, it is necessary to investigate the accuracy of the parameters derived with this method. Only then can one make a well-founded comparison with theoretical predictions. This is a problem which is still widely underestimated and deserves more attention. A first attempt to ascertain the accuracy of the physical parameters is discussed in this thesis.

In the course of this work it was found that a precise value for the angular diameter of the nebula is important for accurately determining physical parameters. The diameter is often determined using a technique called `gaussian deconvolution'. It was found that this method was only weakly founded in theory. Therefore a theoretical investigation was conducted to determine accurate conversion factors for a variety of surface brightness distributions.

The method for modeling nebulae has been applied several times. First, the method was used to model the LMC PN SMP 58. In this research we could tentatively conclude that the nebulae around LMC [WR] central stars are more compact than their galactic counterparts, illustrating how modeling can give clues on the shaping of nebulae.

Second, the method has been used to model the ISO SWS spectra of NGC 7027 and NGC 6543. The SWS spectrum of NGC 7027 shows evidence for evolution, or at least variability, of the central star. The preliminary model is not successful in giving a full explanation of the observed changes in the spectrum, based on the assumption that they are only caused by an increase in the stellar temperature. Nevertheless, one can state that models of this type are needed to gain an understanding of the change in the physical conditions occuring in the central star. When this final analysis is combined with an interpretation of the reported decline of the radio flux, this could result in a unique measurement of the evolutionary speed of the central star of NGC 7027. Using the model of NGC 6543, a rather stringent upper limit could be placed on the He II Lyman continuum emanating from the central star. This is one of the first times that such a constraint could be derived for a stellar spectrum.

Cloudy has also been used to conduct a parameter study of the spectral evolution of a typical post-AGB star, with particular emphasis on the evolution of the infrared colors. Several assumptions have to be made in order to calculate evolutionary tracks for post-AGB stars. A study of the type presented here is important for understanding how these assumptions affect the infrared spectrum of the post-AGB stars. The results of this study may be helpful for understanding the observations made in e.g. the IRAS color-color diagram. This in turn may lead to an improved understanding of mass loss processes, hydrodynamic interactions and evolutionary rates of the central star. Eventually it may lead to better evolutionary calculations. However, we are still far from this goal and our study should only be viewed as a small step towards achieving this goal. Another benefit from this study is that it may help in identifying more efficient search criteria for post-AGB stars and young PN.


An electronic version of my thesis is available in the following formats:

You are welcome to ask for a printed version by sending an email to the address listed below.


GO Back to my home page


Peter van Hoof
Royal Observatory of Belgium
Ringlaan 3
1180 Brussel
Belgium

email: p DOT vanhoof AT oma DOT be

Valid HTML 4.0!